Long-time romantics, in love with love, Janelle and Jacob have been through the gamut of relationships, hook-ups, and undefinable situationships. From schoolyard crushes to long-distance paramours, life in the romance lane has been filled with twists, turns, and quick exits, but neither has given up on finding their destination.

Along the way, they have both picked up shards of armor to protect themselves from the disappointment of failed relationships. But when both of their first dates go south, they find themselves recuperating at the same watering hole and breaking all of their own rules. Will the daylight of the walk of shame show them the way or prove that logic is the best boundary? "If By Starlight" explores the hang-ups and dreams of two helpless romantics, trying to fit all the right pieces together to find true love.